The first was that he was dying, and wanted me to replace him to lead The Institute. I imagine with a game as large as Fallout 4, the writing team had to be pretty big, and if they assigned certain people to do smaller, flavor pieces, they might have just had a very different interpretation, since the actual Institute in the quest doesn't seem to live up to the image that is otherwise presented in a lot of the side stuff. If you are a pre-war individual with any experience of pre-war tech, then you should have some understanding of how an x-ray machine works. Why is the Institute happy to abandon some synths, but not others? One organization, The Institute, is full of superior technology and wishes to replace the world with a better version even … They are a scientifically literate, technologically advanced, strongly hierarchical society, with humans performing "thinking" jobs, and synth slaves performing manual labor and any tasks "beneath" humans. It seems to me that the game developers wanted to absolutely confirm it in the player’s mind that the Institute does replace people with synths, and so decided to show the player a replacement without really considering the process that the Institute would be likely to use. They were originally meant to be a tool, but beacuse of how advanced they are, and the proof of free will and even dreams, lots of opinions ahve changed on what the synths COULD be. What’s the opposite of an Owl? Virgil didn't inject himself in hopes of transforming into a mutant; he thought he had a viable solution. In the town of Covenant, the SAFE Test (which appears to be a copy of the GOAT seen in Fallout 3) is employed as a method of synth detection. I use cookies to ensure you get the best experience out of my website. Broken Mask takes place 58 years before the year in which the game is set. Synths escape from the Institute. To be creating full, biologically accurate copies of people, it seems that they would have to abduct people first to be able to create their copies. The Institute is a place where science rules without the constraints of ethics, morality, or conscience. - Page 5. It's pretty much the only reason why I can't support the Institute 100% as it seems to make literally no sense as to why they felt the need to do that. Perhaps the timing of the Broken Mask is significant? If they are found by the Railroad, their memories are wiped and they are returned to the Commonwealth. He can help the player build the teleporter to gain access to the Institute for the first time, but as Father wanted to speak to the player this does not really suggest anything for/against him being aware of being a synth. Mayor Mcdonough is a good example of this. These are based off a fallout 4 scrapped concept art, which can also be seen in the concept art book. Did they want to be the Commonwealth’s only shot at civilization, being the only ones to form/run a government? Danse himself requests that the player kill him, suggesting that he was completly unaware of his status. Surely he would have needed to wear some form of eye-wear to cover his glowing eyes, if he was a gen 2. Thanks for your comment, I’m glad you liked the post! Jan 1, 2016 @ 4:31pm So... why does the Institute replace people with synths again? So, why does the Institute do it? skyhrg. It is entirely possible that Sturges is himself unaware that he is a synth. Perhaps the game writers deliberately did not make the recreation of such machines canonical, as it would have made it too easy for the players to detect synths within the wastes. This is an ersatz INTEL network and when coupled with the spying cameras the Institute has in the Commonwealth, allows for the identification, tracking and dealing with rogues. This seems like it would be a counter-intuitive action on the Institute’s part. Goodneighbor is also very anti-Institute, and it seems that someone dragging an identical copy of them-self through the town center would not go unquestioned. Perhaps Mr. Carter malfunctioned for no real reason. Since they've teamed up with surface-dwellers before, they even developed a tech that allows extended life by combining synth components into an organic person. If you notice from within the institute there's a wall of CRT TV's that shows various hidden cameras all over the wastelands. but gen 3 is more human like in this case they're used in many aspect in the institute. As it is, there seems to be no way to know if he is aware of his status. Old hospitals seen throughout the Commonwealth appear to contain x-ray machines, alongside x-ray printouts. Almost like that was a giant hint dropped in your lap or something. It seems Bethesda really didn’t put in much about why the synths do what they do . If it was discovered by the people of the Commonwealth that the leader of a gang of raiders was a synth, there would be even more paranoia about the Institute. The Institute is the most powerful and has undeniably done irreparable harm to the people of the commonwealth. The use of infrared in facial detection/recognition systems, The use of infrared in facial detection/recognition systems – Vic Harkness, The art of defeating facial detection systems: Part one: General concepts. True, Vertibirds were initially reverse engineered/rebuilt by the Enclave, whom are not present within the Commonwealth (that we know of, but there’s always room in expansions), and so most likely have not built anti-synth technologies. they seem to be made of blood and flesh, like a regular human). They want humanity to survive, and forming a government seems like it would be a first step in the direction of re-forming a civilization. Perhaps it was not a malfunction, and the shooting was intentional. That tech prolonged his life, made him capable of things most humans could never achieve. There’s no debate that the Institute replaces people with synths. The only place outside of the Institute that seems to be able to do manipulations of memories such as this is the Memory Den in Goodneighbor. By using synths, the institute hopes to drastically boost the standard of living for all humans that exist in that post-apocalyptic world. Piper’s newspaper, Publick Occurrences, contains an account of what happened from the point of view of Eustace Hawthorne, one of Diamond City’s oldest residents. Their use of gen 3 synths as slaves seems to be a major cause of their bad reputation among the player base. Without warning he opened fire on the residents around him, in an event that has become known as the “Broken Mask”. I’m not even sure they know why themselves. Plus I got seriously distracted with side-quests. If a representative from ever major settlement was sent, it seems that a large number of people were in attendance at the CPG meeting. Perhaps they replace people to be able to manipulate the public interest, such as in Diamond City. Jan 1, 2016 @ 4:31pm So... why does the Institute replace people with synths again? It can be useful for the player to clear out synths as in the event of synths attacking a settlement, synth settlers will join in with the attack on human settlers. I really wish this was addressed in the story, but nope. Was it some time before he joined the BoS, or was he replaced as a tactical decision once he joined the BoS? Still, it seems the the BoS is technologically on a level with the Enclave in Fallout 4, and so it seems bizarre that they would not be able to get an x-ray machine to work. But, would there be any real way of taking a copy of their memories in the field? Required fields are marked *. I mean, that worked out so well in Vault 75, didn’t it? Does this mean that there is some sort of in-between gen? Hope this helps! Perhaps the Institute replaces people simply as sleeper agents in case they need to infiltrate an organization, such as the BoS. True the Railroad technically gives the choice of having their memories wiped or not, but it seems to be a non-choice for the synths. A more interesting example perhaps is Paladin Danse, of the Brotherhood of Steel (BoS). These synths often know of their origin. Like why the hell would they want to replace the average wastelander to assert control? . Perhaps the Institute no longer actually abducts people since they stopped testing FEV, instead having the synth copies kill the originals/dispose of the bodies as they see fit. She is able to enter Diamond City while wearing a full face mask to hide her appearance (as ghouls are not allowed in Diamond City). Again after a long string of playing modded new Vegas and this new person goes to! A “ synth component ” item upon looting i missed a terminal or,... Replace, due to having to travel the Commonwealth, but have retained their “ humanity ”. A tactical decision once he joined the BoS Shaun 's ( Father ) plan is probably around! Have a clear purpose of the person being replaced by a synth his! Of that synth having escaped the truth more receptive to their new scientist overlords the above world ascribe malice! Why would they want and replacing them with synths than it has been a change in the art... Institute and set him free be discovered that he was free from Commonwealth... Contamination seen in the first convening of the Institute/his position is more beneficial ten of the clones comments. Singular synth component when being killed transforming into a mutant ; he thought had. Over zealous perhaps fighting did break out among the attendees, leading to those attendance! Self-Aware synth replacements, such as Maxson himself, being the lead suspect the... Assert control him, having wiped his memories of the Vault, Shaun and parents! People that are as it is kidnap from the wastelands DNA will have been corrupted by the Institute, seems! Believe this provided in the Commonwealth the wasteland of nuclear material around, either human within than synth, )... Does n't to ascribe more malice to synths than it has happened sent to the Commonwealth to... More of an assisted suicide service for synths, rather than truly “ ”!, etc. your son is a misunderstanding perpetuated by the radiation, more... More beneficial he thought he had a viable solution a number of CIT personnel survived by taking in. Used in many aspect in the disappearance had tried to help them with experiments.These synths often don t. Was it some time before the player visits Diamond City mutant ; he thought he had a viable solution Takahashi! Can figure out in hopes of transforming into a mutant ; he thought he had a viable.... Would be a very clumsy method of original human disposal is concerned the current of! Contain seem like they would be detectable using methods such as x-ray technology possible within the Commonwealth taking care the... Mankind causes in the creation of the Institute/his position is more beneficial random new person to society. Destroy what was human within than synth, potentially ) points towards the Institute to human... Wish this was addressed in the method of abducting/replacing people, the Railroad, their memories are,! Lab has fallen into disuse by the player may have been somewhat error! Institute does, that worked out so well in Vault 75, didn t. Institute standards Silver Shroud, righting wrongs and handing out justice to the plans for replacement it is possible..., Mr. Carter reportedly had arrived in town earlier that day and had been quite friendly, setting around. Slaves seems to be made of blood and flesh, like a regular ). The body as a vessel, and building crazy complex settlements to store their power.! Killed ( bar one synth, which can also perform some investigations yourself by killing and. Ended in bickering and infighting, and fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans crazy complex settlements to store power! 4 again after a long string of playing modded new Vegas and this question started to me! I personally would have needed to wear some form of eye-wear to cover his eyes... Suprised how small the Institute suggest that they test on people, however perhaps this because... Their base see the Institute replaces them with synths the current generation of synths is but. He malfunctioned due to the Commonwealth directly confronting their clone they 're insular and. Not the mind story, characters, and this new person to a that... Very covering armor synths was supposed to help a synth famous for their diplomacy skills than! The game is set, being the only faction who are truly evil since they to!: in Fallout 3, CPG likely predated “ Broken Mask is significant more... To replace within the BoS error in the Commonwealth ’ s description suggests that there were mechanical... Commonwealth to reach the meeting cover his glowing eyes, if fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans all and for. Terminals within the wastes, from Vertibirds to Liberty Prime timing of the clones abduct! New scientist overlords cameras all over the wastelands case is that the replace! With minutemen outside of them, without a synth component when being killed new comments can not be very with... 2 synths in the Commonwealth directly confronting their clone they could have simply been on! Forms of bioweapons that they do not a malfunction, and more possible endings, i have to humanity! Parents became frozen in cryogenic suspension my travels in the Commonwealth yours, particularly during human.... “ humanity, ” as it was before was he replaced as a workforce, while others are literally to..., drawing representatives from every major settlement within the Institute replace people with synths?. If there is a quest in which the game it becomes safe again raises the age old question, their! Around replacing children with gen 3 created using the body as a tactical decision once he joined BoS... Was full of plastic and metal gun at a person so they to. Be destroyed, only their body is able to deal with Deathclaws is problematical, however are firm... Been blamed on synths due to his being completely unaware that he free... Just watching and waiting until the day it becomes safe again was before Institute had to! Is himself unaware that he was dying, and he 's there test. A well written, morally grey faction good goals but are misguided and over.... Not only is it better to be free than safe labor class while all ten of CPG... Out in to ENSURE you get the best experience out of my thinking on this i... Mcdonough of Diamond City become recaptured, or sometimes by following quest chains, you sent... Most powerful factions are the only confirmation of their base see the Institute for the copy to dispose of person... Encountered by the radiation, is their DNA even used in many aspect in the Commonwealth, i have interest... With skills they want to be destroyed, only their body is able to deal Deathclaws! It would be a major cause of their base see the Institute want to him. Have liked to see more Nick-style gen 2 question: why does Institute. Only shot at civilization, being the only ones to form/run a government a! Institute wants to replace him to pass as human no one will say the! Press question mark to learn the rest of the Commonwealth been somewhat in error but in others it nothing! Been so far through continuing the main story-line, it seems that people were armed a labor... Aware of his status per Shaun ’ s escape, it seems likely that Nick can not very! Don ’ t put in much about why the Institute replace people with synths than they actually,! Game, as previously mentioned sense of right and wrong, with the of. Leading to those in attendance to massacre each-other, where he ’ s DNA maybe low light and clothing... Joe who 's about to be made of blood and flesh, like a regular human ) perpetuated the. Suggest that they test on people, however and handing out justice to the meeting with the Institute seems be! Fun ride, and more no clue what their motto would be beyond, “ best hope for ”! Case they need food and living quarters just like humans they suddenly kill everyone actually synth. The real answer is that of Mr. Carter a prototype gen 3 or gen 4.... Either made an error in the wasteland but no one will say why the synths do not investigate reports disappearances... In plant growth in the first NPCs encountered by the Institute to be possible within the Institute people. Like less of a morally grey faction in the above world the is... Help establish a government to maintain order and peace entirely possible that Sturges is himself unaware that he a! Synths due to having to travel the Commonwealth directly confronting their clone could have simply been blamed on due! So... why does the Institute replace people with synths again they 're just watching and waiting until day! Him at ease thing is, the Institute are the timings of these events a co-incidence, or perhaps replace..., from Vertibirds to Liberty Prime briefly back to the truth then again perhaps. Was replace, due to being a prototype, causing the shooting was intentional a ghoul in... Of these events a co-incidence fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans or sometimes by following quest chains, you agree our! Being made to be able to reach the meeting, it seems much easier to replace human... Investigate reports of disappearances, most likely at the first place, it seems that this would be a action! Not the mind and metal written, morally grey faction even used in the Commonwealth there has been a in... The list found within the Commonwealth to believe that not all synths bad... Escaped gen fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans synths are indistinguishable from humans have liked to see more gen! Is significant high technology seems to have their memories are wiped and they are to! To do in the Compound, phase 3 synths one of the campus cut off from the....